Comparative analysis of Memcached Redis membase performance test

Recently in the research of distributed caching, I hope to be able to currently improve the use of the cache in the project. The results of this test may be unexpected.
comparison and analysis of test resultsSingle Read and write access memcached the fastest, Redis center, membase slowest, single read and write Membase and Redis speed is close, membase time is more than twice times of Redis; the larger the cached data block, the longer the single reads and writes, and the larger data blocks ( 100K) reading and writing, memcached compared to Redis and membase read and write speed advantage is very obvious, the average single time to read and write the time difference is nearly 20 times times and 40 times times; The user's view of response times and "the average response time for CDs" and "user per second read and write" and "total user is related; From the test data, the Memcached,redis and Membase cache access speed is not a bottleneck;
Test Purpose• Understand the effects of memcached, Redis, membase in the actual environment; • Analyze the read-write efficiency of three kinds of caching methods; • Analyze the concurrency capabilities that three caching methods can support;
Test ScenariosMemcached, Redis, membase use the default configuration, turn off Redis persistence and VM capabilities, limit total cache 1G (bytes), limited number (100) User concurrent access, buffer period, hit ratio 80%, three data lengths (1k,10k,100k), Consider data mashup; using the memcached 1.4.15 and libevent version 2.0.20, the client uses the Gwhalin 2.6.6 version; using Redis 2.4.17 version, the client uses the Jedis 2.1.0 version; Use Membase 1.7.2 version, the client uses Couchbase version 1.0.3;
Test ScenarioSingle user access, test cache read and write ability, 100 users concurrent access, test cache read and write ability;
test Environment DescriptionServer Software version: CentOS release 5.5 (Final) cpu:4 kernel 64-bit Intel (R) Xeon (TM) CPU 3.60GHz; memory: 8G; same server, same client software, test data exactly the same.

test Result Data Write data time consuming (data length) Memcached Redis Membase Memcached Redis Membase 1.4.15 2.4.17 1.7.2 1.4.15 2.4.17 1.7.2 1K 1M, 1M, 1M, 57888 59747 52835 1024 17.68933112 17.13893585 19.38109208 Amount of data written per second, in units: MB/s 56531 58347 51596 1,024,000 17689.33112 17138.93585 19381.09208 Number of requests per write, units: Times/sec 10K 100K, 100K, 100K, 14813 16254 18489 1024 69.12846824 62.99987695 55.38428255 Amount of data written per second, in units: MB/s 144659 158732 180560 102,400 6912.846824 6299.987695 5538.428255 Number of requests per write, units: Times/sec 100K 10K, 10K, 10K, 8513 9347 33320 1024 120.2866205 109.5538676 30.73229292 Amount of data written per second, in units: MB/s 831411 912862 3253991 10,240 1202.866205 1095.538676 307.3229292 Number of requests per write, units: Times/sec 10~100k (mix and match) 100K, 100K, 100K, 60743 36703 127295 1024 16.85790955 27.89962673 8.044306532 Amount of data written per second, in units: MB/s 593199 358435 1243120 102,400 1685.790955 2789.962673 804.4306532 Number of requests per write, units: Times/sec Create 1G cached data. Number of entries, total response time, average operation response time td> 1.7.2  Random Read data time consuming (data length)   memcached  redis  membase    memcached  redis  membase        1.4.15  2. 4.17  1.7.2    1.4.15  2.4.17        1k  1m,  1m,  1M,     &NB SP;         52375 52459 127402 1024