Comparison Between Rational Rose and powerdesigner modeling tools

Comparison Between Rational Rose and powerdesigner modeling tools

I,
Their origins
As the world's two most famous case tools, rational
Rose and powerdesigner are well known. Rose was the fist product of rational, the world's largest CASE tool provider at that time. The UML modeling language is
Invented by three giants of rational, booch, Rumbaugh, and Jacob bson. Later, rational was acquired by IBM, So Rose
He was married to a Hao family. Powerdesigner also has a interesting history. The author Wang Xiaoyu is a chinese. When working at SDP software company in France
The case tool was not successful, so I started it freely. I made a whole AMC * designor and sold it in France as "Paris paper expensive". Later, SDP was collected by powersoft.
Purchase, in the same year Sybase, this big yellow bird eats powersoft, so powerdesigner is also amazing, starlight.

However, the two took a very different star route. When Rose came out, it took UML object-oriented modeling and then developed to database modeling, while powerdesigner did the opposite,
First, it was a pure database modeling tool. Later, it moved into object-oriented modeling, business logic modeling, and demand analysis modeling, and eventually became the star of "Three Views.

Due to the influence of the first impression, rose often gives the impression that it is only an object-oriented analysis and design tool, while powerdesigner still gives the impression on database modeling tools.
In fact, the current rose and powerdesigner can both perform database modeling or object-oriented modeling, but there is only a strong emphasis on support.

Ii. Differences between the two

Although rose and powerdesigner have become the stars of high concentration in the field of project analysis and design, but on the specific tool used, different companies, different people, out

Books, habits, or personal preferences often have their own judgment. Because I have been asked to use rose or powerdesigner for analysis and design work in different companies
A more detailed experience.

Rose adopts a big, comprehensive, and all-in-one strategy. Instead of clearly separating database design and object-oriented design, rose only distinguishes different directories. Powerdesigner divides the two into independent

The model files correspond to different design environments, and the associations between models are established through the conversion tools between models. Even for the database design model, powerdesigner also needs to select

Specific database products and their versions, so that the work environment is sensitive to specific databases. So Rose is big, while powerdesigner is more precise and specific. Rose reverse

Engineering, document output, code generation, and other input and output functions are hard and monotonous. powerdesigner provides fine-grained functions in reverse engineering, especially Document Output and code generation.
Control to give users a high degree of freedom.

There are many improvements to the Operation Experience of Rose. Rose prefers to allow users to operate with the mouse, which does not support keyboard operations well. Powerdesigner scores in user experience

Very high, most operations can be completed through the keyboard, with full familiarity with its shortcut keys, powerdesigner will give the designer a feeling of going through the cloud, user interaction is more humane. This

In addition, rose often occupies more resources and is prone to abnormal exit. powerdesigner is lightweight and stable. Therefore, my personal experience for both is "Rose clumsy, PD lisuo ".
The following describes a series of differences between Rose and powerdesigner. We believe that you can use these comparisons to get a glimpse of the difference and provide a reference when choosing tools. III,
Differences between model organization and hierarchy

1. The model organization Rose puts the database model and the object model together. During data table model design, there is no characteristic. Powerdesigner separates the two and organizes the model.

The hierarchical relationship is: Workspace-> model type-> model of specific language/database-> package-> folder-> digoal-> design element. In

When creating a model file, you will be asked to select the model type. After selecting the model type, you can also select the language and version-related classification under the model type. Different design models correspond to different stages of software engineering, such as business models and

The requirement model belongs to the project requirement stage, while the object model belongs to the outline and detailed design stage, and the database model belongs to the detailed design stage. Although there is a strong internal relationship between them, the difference is also obvious.
Put them together, just like putting monkeys and orangutan in the same cage. In order to balance and balance the two, the result is that both are not well supported.

Figure 1 new model window (PD)

Figure 2 new model window (Rose)

Powerdesinger supports database modeling and object-oriented model conversion through model conversion tools. However, rose cannot convert objects to tables or tables to objects.


2. The workspace powerdesigner has the concept of a workspace. Multiple design model files can be opened in a workspace at the same time, while rose can only open one design file at the same time.
Timing. If you need to refer to other Rose design models, you need to turn off the existing models repeatedly and open the reference model, which seems to be relatively inefficient in design. The difference between the two is similar to that between eclipse and
The difference between JBuilder is that eclipse can open multiple projects at the same time, while JBuilder can only open one project at the same time.

3. The design interface powerdesigner's design interface can be moved up and down, while rose can only move to the right, down, in addition. Powerdesigner can put Model Elements

It is many times larger, and Rose can only zoom in to a normal multiple. However, the overview tool of Rose allows users to quickly locate specific areas in the design area, which is similar to a small location commonly used in the game interface.
Figure, pretty good;

Figure 3
Overview tool (Rose)

In powerdesigner, you can use the F8 shortcut to view the digoal overview chart, but you have to zoom in to locate the Location Area.
4
Support for models and languages
? Strength and breadth of support for the design model

Powerdesigner supports both object model and database modeling. In addition, it also supports conceptual model, business model, requirement model, XML model, information flow model, and self-built

Analysis and Design of the model. However, the support for the following models is relatively Elementary, and these models are rarely used in practical applications. The highlight of powerdesigner is in the database.
Modeling and object model design.

For database models, powerdesigner supports more than 20 types of databases. It also provides separate support for different versions of the same database to provide databases and versions when designing database models.
Related designs. For object-oriented models, powerdesigner supports 11 mainstream languages and provides separate support for Java 5.0.

Rose is basically an object model design tool with rough support for database models. Embedded only supports Oracle
8. The support for other database designs must be obtained by installing plug-ins, and the support for fine-grained content such as physical storage parameters of the database is rough. Rose's object model mainly supports
Java, Vc, and VB.

? Java support

Rose provides better support for the Java language, not only for JDK of different versions (but rose 2003 does not support JDK
5.0). It also provides embedded support for specific Java products and design patterns (such as EJB, CORBA, Servlet, and gof), which are directly reflected in Rose.

. Because of this, the heavy historical burden on Rose, such as language-level things like EJB and CORBA, is easy to change and constantly updated. How can we position and influence these products?
When it is reduced, it is a difficult problem for the designers to give up and ensure version compatibility.

Powerdesigner only supports language-level Object Design and does not involve specific products within the language. Secondly, because its design work zone is related to the specific model type and language subdivision, rather
It is directly supported in the main menu, so powerdesigner is more calm during upgrade.

This is also the reason why powerdesigner can be upgraded at a rate of one version every year, and Rose has been put into the market for the new version after version 2003. Otherwise, it will take the money of IBM
And R & D capabilities will not respond slowly to the market.

5. Comparison of Input and Output Functions
5.1 Reverse Engineering

From the reverse engineering function of converting program code to design model, Rose is more like an IDE, which performs deep semantic check on program code that requires reverse engineering operations, if such code references exist
For classes other than the class library, the reverse engineering will fail, and the window will be in the unresponsive state for a long time before the report fails.

Powerdesigner only performs a simple syntax check on the program code that requires reverse engineering. This simple syntax check does not involve packages and associations between classes. It only checks whether the class name matches the class file name or not.
Missing "}"
And other syntactic content. Even if an error exists, powerdesigner allows you to ignore the error and continue reverse engineering operations. This Loose Restriction brings great convenience.

Figure 4 reverse engineering failure selection (PD)

After the error is ignored, powerdesigner tries its best to fix the error. For example, if the corresponding "}" is missing in the code, it will be filled in. The class name and file name are inconsistent, and the class file name will be ignored to keep the class name unchanged.

Rose has been promoting the idea of two-way communication between IDE and Design Engineering: After completing the Model Design in rose, it exports the code used by IDE. After the IDE code is adjusted, it reverse engineering to Rose. Management

The concept is very beautiful and attractive, but in implementation, few development teams often do this. Generally, the CASE tool is only used in the analysis and design phase, and even a large proportion of designers only use it as a drawing tool.

After entering the coding development stage, a large number of classes and methods not involved in the design will be added. if you reverse these non-skeleton things to the case tool, instead, it will make the original clear design confused.

Flowers, water in the month. Therefore, even if the original analysis model needs to be adjusted during encoding, the design model is usually manually adjusted instead of being synchronized through reverse engineering. After all, the analysis design is skeleton, while the encoding is flesh-and-blood.

The two have different attributes. If you really need frequent code and UML conversions, it is best to use a tool similar to together, which is embedded into the IDE so that the code and model Convertor
Quick.

5.2 document export Function

Powerdesigner provides fine-grained control over document export. You can not only set content items contained in the document, but also set the format of content items. For example, whether the exported table structure is a package
Including the name, data type, remarks, and other items. The width proportion, color, and font size of these items in the table column are different.

Powerdesinger
12.0 added a milti-model for multi-model document integration and export.
The report model allows you to generate a unified document using multiple models as input, so that model design is separated by stages and documents are integrated in a unified manner.

Since the export settings of the powerdesigner document are very fine, it is not easy to set a document export mode. Powerdesinger provides three common
You can also customize the template. Templates can be used to quickly export the design model documents.

Rose does not have the concept of an export template, and cannot set export items and formats. You can only publish model documents in the built-in mode of Rose.

5.3 Export Code

When exporting the code of the design model, powerdesigner provides fine-grained control, not only on the object level, but also on the code level (for example, whether to generate the code for the field remarks,
The foreign key code is declared in the table body Code or in the external Declaration of the table body), and Rose does not provide code export control, and can only export the code in the way it is set in the system.

Figure 5
Database Model Export settings (PD)
5.4 Generate Test Data

Powerdesigner can generate a batch of test data for a data table, and you can also create rules for generating test data. This function facilitates the development and testing of the initial project. Rose
Does not provide similar functions.