"Three Kingdoms Kill" lawsuit "Three Kingdoms Chop" PK3 hour is tied

"Three Kingdoms Kill" Caocao "Three Kingdoms Chop" the "Three Kingdoms Kill" Diao Cicada "Three Kingdoms chop" Diao Cicada yesterday 8:45, West L. District the court.　　A famous game "Three Kingdoms Kill", sued a newly released game "Three Kingdoms chop". The plaintiff "Three Kingdoms kill" alleged that "three Kingdoms chop" violated their copyright.　　Two representatives of the game, in the court to debate 3 hours, not divided.　　The plaintiff Hangzhou winger Network Technology Co., Ltd., is the "three Kill" operator Shanghai Shanda Company wholly-owned subsidiary.　　The first defendant, Hangzhou Tian Chang Network Technology Co., Ltd., is the "three to chop" operators; the second defendant, Hangzhou fun play Digital Technology Co., Ltd., is the "Three Kingdoms chop" game developers.　　Both sides are seated and the presiding judge announces the hearing. The plaintiff solicitor (Luo, Zhejiang ze da law firm) Read the indictment form: request the Court to decree the defendant immediately stop operating the "Three Kingdoms chop" online game or delete (infringing) content, stop the sale of the "Three Kingdoms Chop" card, decree the defendant on his website, and in the Journal of Computer World to apologize, to eliminate the impact　　Award the defendant 500,000 yuan for the plaintiff ... The plaintiff said, "Three Kingdoms chop" in the game background, form, content and so on many aspects, adopts the synonym substitution, the word order inversion and so on, the change "Three Kingdoms Kill" Personage's choice, the personage's skill, the game Card's utility, the game rule's text description, causes the two to constitute substantially similar, its behavior has constituted "the plagiarism others work"　　[Page] The lawyers in the court, each show the game of the full set of cards. The plaintiff's lawyer put "Three Kingdoms chop" and "Three Kingdoms Kill" in the characters and skills made one by one control, will be a similar point, made a thick about 1 centimeters of written material.　　The plaintiffs ' lawyers say similarities are mainly in "skill descriptions".　　The plaintiff selected several characters from the card to testify-Cao Cao, "The Three Kingdoms Kill" in the Caocao, the right hand fling a big red silk robe, body wears the black yellow stripes the armour, the head wears the fiery red Ying the battle helmet, "The Three Kingdoms chop" in the CAO, only shows the chest above, the hair plate, the expression is cold.　　The plaintiff said, "Kill the Three Kingdoms" in the description of the skills of Caocao-Ganxiong: You can immediately get the cards that hurt you: master, when you need to use (or play) a "flash", you can launch the escort.　　The description of Cao's skill in "Three Kingdoms chop"--male PA: Injured after the blood, immediately get the damage to you the card, the owner: by "Chop", "Million Arrows Qi" attack, you can please Wei will help you out of the "flash" (Master technology).　　"Male pa" and "Ganxiong" similar, "the owner" and "guard" is no different, the following description is basically the same.　　Diao Chan "Three Kingdoms Kill" in the Diao cicada, long hair fluttering, graceful dance, Jade arm high lift, waving ribbons, "three chopped" in the Diao cicada, chest shoulder bare, long hair shawl, wearing red peony, face slightly sad. The plaintiff said that the description of the Diao Cicada in the killing of the Three Kingdoms is a divisive one: at the licensing stage, you can discard a card and choose two male characters. Closed Month: Round end stage, can touch aCard.　　"Three chop" described as--closed month: After the end of the round, can be 1 cards from the stack touch: the licensing stage, can discard 1 cards ...　　Both have "closed months", the following description is basically consistent ...　　Zhang Fei, "The Three Kingdoms Kill" in Zhang, a face fierce, round head stare, body wearing armour, whispering Wind, "Three Kingdoms chop" in Zhang Fei, also show chest above, Dame.　　Description: "Kill the Three Kingdoms"-roaring: You can use any number of "kill" in the licensing phase.　　"Three Kingdoms Chop"-When thousand: The card stage, may out any quantity "chop".　　The expression of the whole sentence is basically consistent, just "kill" changed to "chop". The above statement, the accused lawyer (Zhejiang Provincial Bar Association, director of Intellectual Property Professional Committee Wangjin, Cheng, associate professor of intellectual property law, Zhejiang Industrial and Commercial University strongly retorted--"Three Kingdoms Kill" card game is mainly a game design idea, the rules of the game is a typical thought, belongs to the expression of very few ingredients, limited belong to the expression of the composition,　　The defendant never reproduced the plaintiff's rule description directly; "Three Kingdoms Chop" the first version of the Generals adviser, there are 42 characters, online games, there are more than 50 characters, has been planning more than 100 people, and "three kill" so far only 25 people.　　Thus, the defendant does not constitute infringement of the plaintiff.　　The defendant believed that "Three Kingdoms chop" the picture design and the style, with "Three Kingdoms kill" completely different, "the Three Kingdoms chop" is more exquisite.　　Since then, the two sides to debate on several other issues, you come to me, but also a few of the confrontation ...　　After the trial, neither side agreed to mediate, the judge will choose the day of sentencing.　　Three Kingdoms and "Three Kingdoms Kill" Three Kingdoms (A.D. 220 ~280 year), because of a "the Two Kingdoms", and because of an easy transit, the history of the division of confrontation known to the world-Wei (Wei), Shu (SHU), East Wu (WU) pillars, infighting, the world a magnificent, everywhere full of vitality.　　Cao Ganxiong, cruel suspicion, complex and changeable, Liu Bei Virtuous, Hong Yi Generous, delegate, Zhuge Ming, has been a fetish ... Cottage, grass boat borrow arrows, Ling, Sanying war BU, mistake ...　　Every story is gripping. "Killing of the Three Kingdoms" is a popular desktop game (most of the use of paper materials plus exquisite model AIDS, it is a face-to-face game, very much emphasis on communication, like Mahjong, chess, poker, it combines the background of China's Three Kingdoms, to the identity of the clues to the card as a form, set history, literature, art in one, Online edition is now available.　　Added to the end of the game name, the network game.　　In the "killing of the Three Kingdoms" game, players play a three-period generals, combined with this bureau identity, alliances, after a round of strategy and action to win the final victory. "Three Kingdoms Kill" currently has 5 versions. The Standard Edition has 153 card cards. At present, the latest standard version of the card price of 39 yuan, the newspaper booth, Xinhua bookStores are available for sale.　　Online version does not need to pay, but in order to play more interesting, it is necessary to buy props, equipment, with Gong (100 coupons = 1 yuan) to buy, different equipment cost different. "Three Kingdoms Kill" in total 4 kinds of identities: The Lord, Anti-Thief, loyal, Mole. (Edit Zhang Xing)