Wang Xuming interpretation of "Student sexual Contact" event: adults should take responsibility

Two video, two secondary schools, two incidents of harassment, the protagonist is middle school students, the location is the school classroom, mobile phone upload, network reprint, human flesh search, when the campus events evolved into a public topic, the privacy of minors how should we protect? Chongqing fake candidates list should not be published still dispute, has been exposed to the arts champion under great pressure, punishment, the party's psychological how should we pay attention? All kinds of communication channels are growing today, to protect the growing minors, family, society, the law also need to make what effective measures?　　"News 1+1" for you to resolve. Studio presenter (Dong Qian): In recent times, two videos of sexual contact between minors in schools have caused a lot of tremors in adult society. What should adult society do when minors make mistakes and even when they do? Tolerance or condemnation? We now often say that the protection of minors is the right, but this degree should be zoned where?　　The special observer is invited to our studio today Mr. Wang Xuming, what does Mr. Wang think of the two incidents?　　Wang Xuming (guest observer): After these two incidents, I think that, as an adult, especially as educators, although such things happen in contrast to the country's more than 100 million primary and secondary students, compared to the national millions of candidates is a minority, is individual, but it is very sad.　　Moderator: Before we begin today's commentary, let's backtrack on what happened at the school in Shunyi.　　Explanation: In the early morning of Friday, a video of a classroom in Beijing's Shunyi V was posted online, and in the video, several boys in school uniforms openly molested a female classmate in the classroom. Recently, the network began a large range of the video of the reprint and discussion, shocked also have netizens on the video of the parties launched human flesh search.　　Soon, in the Baidu Post bar, someone posted a video of several people's relevant information, a netizen also provided three of teenagers of personal photos and names, and even an alleged one of the teenager's QQ number was also publicized.　　This is our reporter landed in the Baidu Bar Shunyi V, see a post, the administrator told netizens that the content of the post will be cleaned up and the time shown is July 3 night 7:11, and this time the video as well as the human flesh search caused by it has been on the internet for more than 10 hours. Meanwhile, Beijing's Shunyi district education and Public Security department also launched an investigation into the video. Some insiders said that seven or eight students accompanied by parents, to the temporary investigation point to be investigated, although it is Friday, the school is also about to leave, but the Education department heads and the Shunyi v Middle School students are doomed to be difficult to relax.　　Curious reporters at the school gate at school time, from each student to inquire about the video party's personal information. and was the Netizen human Flesh search and published the QQ number of the boy to the media that he has nothing to do with this matter, but the QQ number of exposure let him many times by the netFriends attack.　　And then Shunyi District the head of the Board of Education also implored the news media and the vast number of netizens, from the protection, care for the youth and health of the position, do not be too paparazzi, disclosure of information about the victim. In the aftermath of the Shunyi v video event, a period of time before the uproar of Zhejiang Cixi Vocational school events, still retain the traces of the network lively. In this 3-minute 19-second mobile video, a number of boys are harassing a girl in the classroom.　　After the netizen in the crazy human flesh search to find the Cixi professional actress QQ Space, the high school girl's personal information on the network was published. "Sorry, I can't help it, I will choose to leave this world."　　"This is a Cixi video of the heroine in an article published on June 21, the article on their own behavior is full of remorse, in the network media various discussions and search unlimited amplification, such words appear somewhat powerless."　　Now, on the Shunyi V and Cixi High School video and posts have been a large number of deleted, the media did not do a further report on the incident, but the network for such information in pursuit of the trend has become increasingly fierce. In the last two days, a campus-class indecent video from Shanghai has again become a hot spot on the internet. However, soon after the media investigation, suspected that this is a cyber spoof, the parties and schools are unable to verify. But the frequent reprint quantity, the Netizen to the video's exhaustive search, but presents the more formidable aspect than the event itself.　　Who in the world is in need and is creating such information? Moderator: These two videos spread on the internet, they are the same nature?　　We're going to connect you, Professor Piam, director of the juvenile Delinquency and juvenile Justice Research Center, HI.　　Pilly Army (professor of China University of Political Science and Political science): Hello. Moderator: You see this happened in Cixi, the information provided to us from the news that the girls are not forced, what kind of behavior? What happened in the Shunyi school, the girl was forced, and what kind of behavior?　　How do you characterize it? Pilly: Now we think of it on the Internet as male harassment and indecent assault on girls. But from the Cixi incident, as if the girls are voluntary, from the Shunyi, the force of this trend is not very obvious, there is a more active male to ask, and girls are half-hearted this situation.　　So as we adults think of them as harassment and indecent assault, is a kind of loss of sexual ethics, but never seen by adults, he thought that this is a kind of sex game, or this is a kind of opposite sex to the physiological aspect of an inquiry.　　Moderator: Professor Pi, do you think they are making a mistake or are they breaking the law?　　Pilly Army: If it is not that kind of hard forced behavior, there is no obvious violation of the woman's will, I think is not a criminal act, from the illegality is also difficult to construct, it is likely to be a more serious moral behavior, that is, immoral behavior. Moderator: There's another line.What kind of behavior is it that we are able to see these two videos on the internet because some students are filming them and uploading them to the Internet?　　Pilly: If uploaded and released, this is a violation of the privacy of others, but also the dissemination of this so-called pornographic information is suspected, in this regard may be illegal.　　Moderator: When these two things appear, now many people, especially in adult society, many of the evaluation, that these children are morally bankrupt, there is no Li Yilian, how do you think of these evaluations? Pilly: The adult world don't easily label them. Because, first of all, we see from this episode that our adult world is not really responsible for the sex education of teenagers and what they call adolescent education, and really can provide them with the information they need from the regular channels. From this adolescent education in our country today, we do not believe that it meets or is a legitimate need to meet the needs of adolescents. When we do not have the right channels, or not so smooth, teenagers will certainly use a very state or a morbid way. In fact, in this area, these two cases are between the opposite sex need to explore the mystery of this sex, sexual mystery, and our adult world, our sex education in the middle of sex as a mysterious, ugly, evil, so there may be a misunderstanding of education. So here we think that sex should be a natural phenomenon, a normal physical phenomenon, and it is likely to be morally unethical to make it easy for the children to objectively and positively carry out this education, rather than to have them explore in their own way, in the case of our proper channel blockage,　　may also be dangerous. Moderator: Professor Pi, my last question to you, how do you think these children should protect them?　　In these two video events, the boys and girls are good? Pilly Army: As minors, whatever the way, even punishment is to protect, that is, we are a comprehensive protection for minors, this protection has both privacy protection, but also to their future future protection, So this should be the objective situation of the development of the adults themselves, it is not unusual for them to appear at this time, we adults should bear our own responsibility in this respect.　　For children, it is still important for them to have a positive education. Moderator: Well, thank you, Professor Leather. Mr. Wang you see, just now Professor Pi repeatedly said, such a child of age, should not be used in the adult world of some of the evaluation nailed to them. I think it might be a promoter. These actions may be due to this right and wrong view of the adult world, and even the moral sense, that he did it wrong, so we have to go to the human flesh search out, we can condemn them, but the problem isWhat are the effects of these condemned words, some of them even worse, when they are listed on these children?　　Wang Xuming: It is true that we should see the subject of the matter as minors, so when we are thinking about this as an adult, we really shouldn't treat them as adults, we should treat them as minors, and this will involve how to grasp the problem when dealing with a series of problems. I think we are on the Internet human Search, these netizens do have his positive side, for example, condemnation, criticism, to promote the work of correction.　　But on the other hand, if this degree of expansion, for example, his name is public, even his QQ number is public, I think it is really a harm to minors. Moderator: You have just mentioned a degree of question, as an adult society how to criticize them?　　Because it is impossible not to criticize, not to criticize is an indulgence of this kind of no bottom line behavior, but you say how to criticize, when these sometimes is slashing some criticism to these children's head, what will affect them? Wang Xuming: I also feel that, in this case, personally, I don't feel the need to slashing. As far as I am concerned, Professor Pi is more interested in discussing this issue from the angle of the legal system. I think it is true, this question shows that we are in the education work, especially for the students, just now Professor Pi talked about psychological education, in fact, I think far more than the psychological education of adolescence, for example, I think the students of this kind of shame heart education.　　Although we say that the girl is a smile does not show such a request, in the past feudal times, now reform and opening up, we do not have such a request, but there is a minimum of human privacy part of a protection, such a request or some, such a necessary sense of shame or should be instilled and educated students.　　Moderator: You think it's more than just ...　　Wang Xuming: The problem of puberty physiology education.　　Moderator: I saw these things come out later, there is a Cixi education Bureau of the relevant people, he said something like this, he said, "This is an occasional incident of this age, is a joke with the head," How do you comment?　　Wang Xuming: Of course I wish things could have been a joke like the director said.　　To take a step back, even if the joke is over the head, I also feel that this is too important to criticize, because the joke can be opened, over the head should be criticized. Moderator: There is another point of view that this should not depend on this child, because the child's world, is a minor's world is often a map of the adult world, he is more intuitive, he saw some things in the adult world, he reflected in his daily life to go, out of this kind of thing, should reflect on the adult world　　, and should not blame these underage children more. Wang Xuming: This has to be said from both ends. I think this statement does have a very positive side, I also agree with this side, for adults, educators should reflect on.　　But it is true, we these children are not three years old, five years old, I see these two events are the second and middle school students, should be said to know some things, has been in the process of moving towards adult, so I think they should bear a certain responsibility.　　Moderator: Well, we have said so much, we may wish to mention some constructive practices, when this kind of thing, in order to no longer happen such things, what should be done, and protect them, and to criticize them? Wang Xuming: I imagine Beijing Shunyi, the Education administration, has issued an appeal to the media not to be overly hyped.　　In addition, our website Management department early on the block, and now open this site, has not been able to find these videos, I think this is the protection measures, should be said to be very timely, very good.　　Of course, I think protection has another meaning, as the school, as the parents of the students, indeed should strengthen education, education itself is a protection. Moderator: We now live in a pluralistic society, minors, like us, is also in this society, in the face of the various temptations, all kinds of even can be called the trap of things, what should minors do? What should we do to protect them as adults?　　Our program will continue at a later moment. Moderator: How to protect the rights of minors?　　Next we look at a more extreme event that occurs. Explanation: This Tuesday, the Chongqing Municipal Admissions Office issued a circular to abolish 31 candidates who violate the nationality component to qualify for this year's admission. It is worth mentioning that the circular also said that, in view of the fact that the majority of the 31 candidates are minors, in order to protect minors in accordance with the law, in line with the principles of education and protection, and conducive to growth, it does not disclose the names of 31 candidates and related information. This approach has also been supported by the Ministry of Education. At this point, the uproar over the days of the bonus incident to the pause.　　However, in the hustle and bustle, we should not think about how to deal with these young people who are at fault. June 23, Chongqing University entrance exam scores release, two days later, the Chongqing Arts champion was a national ingredient fraud. In the early hours of July 2, the Peking University admissions Office made it clear that the candidate would not be admitted, and that on the same day, HKU refused to accept the interview.　　July 7, Chongqing City Admissions Office issued a circular, 31 illegal candidates were canceled this year admission eligibility.　　15 days, from the college entrance examination to the false, and then to be rejected by the university, finally this year, we can not learn, we can not really know 15 days, the arts champion has gone through a kind of mental process, only from the media reports to capture some words. July 2 0 o'clock in the morning 40 points, know that Beijing University refused admission, he cried a. He was disappointed and annoyed to learn that he had been rejected by HKU., locked himself in the house, he was under great pressure every day. For two weeks, in the media's full coverage, many of the comments pointed to the college entrance examination of the fair, fair, or the admission system of openness and transparency, only a small number of media and expert netizens noticed a detail, that is, his parents for his change of national identity, he was only 14 years old. According to his father in the media interview, he was only 18 years old in December this year, is still a minor, experts pointed out that this means that he was still under the protection of the law of minors protected children, there is no independent civil capacity. The forgery of national identity is an act that he can not foresee, even more can not stop. After being exempted from public office, his father acknowledged the mistake and was willing to take responsibility.　　At the same time, the child does not necessarily become a pillar of society, but certainly not the dregs of society, or hope that society can give children a chance.　　On the night of the cancellation of admission, the liberal arts scholar first opened his mouth to speak, while understanding his father, he said, I have paid the price, I hope that the candidates in the future with me as a mirror. Moderator: For Hokugawa should not be rejected by Beida, about such a view can be said to be entirely separate, then we will connect Beijing to ask day law firm Zhou Lawyer, Zhou Lawyer is that Beida should not reject Hokugawa.　　Hello, Counselor Zhou.　　Zhou (Beijing day law firm lawyer): Hello, Host good.　　Moderator: Why do you have such a view? Zhou: Because I think the right to education it is actually a basic human right, but also the basic rights of our country's constitution, is not to be arbitrarily deprived of, unless he exercised this right, he will materially damage the rights of others. Like the national component of the fake examinee Hokugawa, he actually does not now have the benefit of a false national component, he is entirely based on the actual test results, rather than through the false minority bonus score, such as the university should be accepted, because he did not harm the interests of others,　　It is also impossible to undermine the rights of others, not to admit, or to abolish the admission of qualifications, in fact, is a denial of his right to education, and does not have a legitimate reason. At the same time, it is not reasonable to admit him, because this national component of fraud needs to punish the perpetrators of fraud, and the perpetrator has actually been punished, such as the examinee itself is not a fraud, should not punish him, and should not be deprived of the right to education to punish him. Or when the democratic elements are falsified, they exist like ... Mistake, may have a psychological flaw, but not good faith is not exactly the need for education? Also need to safeguard the right to education, so that he was educated, to make him more honest, but also the purpose and purpose of education. I think what is more important here is that the school does not admit a student, and it actually involves the basic right of his right to education, which must be based on legal basis. Now we see noThe admission of him, or the cancellation of his admission, is based solely on an internal administrative guidance document issued by the three departments of Minfer, the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Public Security, which in fact simply cannot be used as a legal basis for abolishing the fundamental rights of a citizen.　　Moderator: Lawyer Zhou, I interrupted you, your point of view is that Beida should not refuse Hokugawa, because such words and so on deprived him of the right to education, we are sitting in the studio now a long time engaged in education, Mr. Wang Xuming, Mr. Wang you agree with the lawyer Zhou's point of view? Wang Xuming: I don't agree.　　I think colleges and universities in accordance with the provisions of the relevant departments, the abolition of non-compliance candidates in the year of admission qualifications, I think that this examinee has made you to pay the necessary price, for more stringent compliance of the broad masses of candidates is fair, I think not because of the abolition of his admission qualification this year, is to deprive his citizens of the right to learn. Moderator: Lawyer Zhou, did you hear that?　　You think Mr. Wang said there is no reason, I did not deprive him of his life, I just deprived him for a year. Zhou: Your partial deprivation of the right to education is also a denial of the right to education, the right to education as a citizen's basic rights, the deprivation of it, you must have legal reasons, legal basis, and must have a clear legal basis.　　The documents of the departments concerned, which are now on the basis of an internal administrative guidance document, clearly do not deprive citizens of their basic rights, which is the effect of such a legal basis.　　Wang Xuming: As far as I know, this rule is not an internal document, it is a rule that is widely known on the Internet. Zhou: This file is published by an object to make a notification, what is the object it notifies? The provincial Department of Education, the Education Bureau, the notice is that these departments, that it is actually an internal, is that its application of the main body is the educational administration, is actually notice to them, in itself is not to say that, like our laws and regulations through the State, through the channels of law, form, full disclosure, to restrain all citizens　　It does not have such a nature. Moderator: I interrupted you a week lawyers, because this is the legal argument, we have limited time today, not here to argue, I would like to listen to your opinion, is the face of such a college entrance examination of such a thing, you think there is any way to protect him? On the one hand let him know that this is wrong, on the other hand to protect him.　　Of course you say he is an educated right to be hijacked, but perhaps more for his growth, there is no way to make up for? Zhou: I think first of all I would like to look at this issue from the perspective of the right to education, in fact, involving the right to education of citizens such a major issue, we see the two days before the Peking University also said that the internal access to such an agreement, two days ago actually, we also saw the Zhongqing Education Department said to retain his admission qualifications, Results two days to find a big change, Beida said no admission, Chongqing Education Department in the public opinion of a discussion under the talk, we also canceled the admission qualification. We have seen that a major problem involving the right to education of citizens, in the opinion of the authorities concerned, is so arbitrary in the institutions of higher learning that the deprivation of the rights of a citizen is to be denied and given, and that, once deprived of such rights, there is no remedy in itself.　　At present I feel that some people like Hokugawa, they do not know what to do, I think this is a very big problem. Moderator: OK, thank you for explaining some of your views. Mr. Wang, just now we also said, to cancel such a college entrance examination of his admission to Peking University, what is the purpose? What lessons do you have for this child in order to give this student?　　Does this aim reach, in this way? Wang Xuming: In fact, I think we have always said that protection, protection, protection has a twofold meaning, a heavy meaning is the meaning of our usual meaning of protection. Another important implication is that the wrong students, students or other people, the appropriate treatment, criticism, education, is also a protection.　　Of course, I particularly feel that this is a protective measure for the 30-odd students who are the so-called candidates for ethnic minorities, and the Chongqing Board of Education has not published their names. Of course, I also particularly regret that a lot of media hype the so-called champion So-and-so a classmate, this pressure is indeed unnecessary, is excessive.　　But I think it is fair for the vast majority of the students, whether they are 30 or more, to deal with the most law-abiding candidates.　　Moderator: We're going to think for the vast majority of these students, in order to ensure their fairness, we have to sanction these 31 counterfeiters, but they are also a group of people, they are also a very precious individual, if such sanctions make their future irreparable such losses, then who will make up for them?　　Wang Xuming: This involves a problem, is the wrong person must remember, when you make a mistake, to pay the price for the error. Just now, most of these candidates, albeit minors, but only 17 years old, 18 years old, perhaps they change the national time 12 years old, 13 years old, do not know anything, but with the growth of age, to 16 years old, 17 years old, 18 years old, know their own nation is changed, anyhow, I said,　　The heart of shame should have, lying is to be ashamed, is to be shy, should not lie, this education I think should have this basic judgment, the child should have.　　Moderator: Today we have been stressing that shame, whether it is the body of this shame, or the reputation of ourselves, even this shame, it should be nurtured. Wang Xuming: So through these two things, I particularly feel that we are in education, although we have an opinion on strengthening the ideological education of minors, this is a very important programmatic document, but in the implementation of specific work when, for example, to strengthen students ' sense of shame and so on, and so on, there is much work to be done.