Comparison between computer and Mathematical Physics and Chemistry "highest" journal ZT

In my opinion, prolactin and Jacs should be roughly equivalent to major conferences in the CS field.

Taking the network as an example, this is a very large field, and the proportion of CS should be no less than 10% (see
PhD student ratio ). Every year, the major conferences of the network are sigcomm,
Mobicom, Infocom, ICNP, and mobihoc. Sigcomm and mobicom have about 30 articles each.
Regular papers; about 200 Infocom articles; about 40 ICNP and mobihoc documents each. In this way,
A total of about 350 articles are added. In addition, it was posted at an important "semi-Network Conference" such as sigmetrics.
There are up to 400 online articles.

Considering that half of the network articles are from EE, it actually belongs to the major networking conference papers of CS.
There are only about 200 articles. This quantity is still less than 10% of the total number of topics published per year by prolactin or Jacs.

I have not collected any physical/chemical articles from nature/science. But I feel like its quantity
Still far exceeds the number of jacm articles.

Sender: sir)

Comparison between computer and Mathematical Physics and Chemistry "highest" Journals

(You are welcome to repost this article. Do not modify it when you repost it .)

It sounds like a story about the battle of Guan Gong and Qin Qiong. However, in today's increasingly frequent communication among various disciplines
Playing with Qin Qiong may not be a bad thing. At least, we can let the audience know that Guan Gong is not from the Three Kingdoms.
Qin Qiong and Qin Qiong are not the same as Guan Gong of the reincarnation. Disclaimer: This article does not intend to provoke disputes between disciplines.
Please stop here.

Now, the athletes are playing. Please applaud:

(1) Journal of the ACM (jacm)
This student is the leader of the computer science journal and claims to only publish the "the most significant work going
On in computer science ". Note that it is the most, and people do not hesitate to use the most adjectives
Advanced, without modesty such as "one of" or "some. It is said that the post is required
Must have long-term value (lasting value) and be indeed outstanding in its field (truly)
Outstanding in its field ).

(2) Annals of Mathematics (Annals)
This student is relatively modest and only says that he is one of the main mathematics journals in
World, but everyone knows it is No. 1 in the mathematics journal.

(3) Physical Review Letters)
Physics is not the same as mathematics or CS. It can be used for nature/science. But if you want
Find a leader in a journal, and most people will choose "prolactin. Considering that his goal is to publish major
Advances in all aspects of physics, this option seems good.

(4) Journal of the American Chemical Society (Jacs)
Chemistry is also available in nature/science. However, in all chemistry publications, the status of Jacs
Obviously unshakable --- "the world's most respected Chemical Journal ".

First comparison: publication cycle

Jacm: Dual-monthly magazine-Issue 6 each year
Annals: Dual-monthly magazine-Issue 6 each year
Prolactin: weekly-about 50 issues each year
Jacs: weekly magazine-about 51 issues each year

Comment: This comparison seems meaningless, but it implies two different orientations to some extent: jacm
And annals, and prolactin and Jacs.

Second comparison: number of articles published in the last five years
2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 average annual

Jacm 30 33 50 30 39 36.4
Annals 65 59 51 53 44 54.4
Prolactin 3937 3847 3225 3196 3164
Jacs 3437 3215 3039 2717 2366

Comments: From the first result, we can estimate that the number of articles in jacm and Annals is much smaller than that in prolactin and Jacs, but I'm afraid few
Yes

I think that the average number of articles published per year on top of that on top of jacm is nearly 100 times that on average?

Item 3 Comparison: length (number of pages) of ten randomly selected articles)

Average
Jacm 67 16 26 30 61 109 15 38 14 45 42.1
Annals 24 61 33 45 74 21 47 16 92 69 48.2
Prolactin 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Jacs 2 5 5 3 2 9 2 6 11 10 5.5

Comment: it seems that there are no more than four pages in the prolactin, so every article is 4 pages. Jacs has relatively short communications.
And a slightly longer full papers. However, even if it is full paper, it is at most 10 pages. In contrast, jacm and Annals
The average length of the chapter is about 10 times that of prolactin and Jacs. The longest part of the sample has 109 pages!

Result: No.

Comment: the best apple and the best watermelon are not a concept. The "highest journal" of different disciplines is also not
Concept.