Hunan Financial Securities response to the "graphite door" researcher said it was implicated

China Baoan "Graphite door" incident has become a "buck" game. Prior to that, a number of securities research reports have mentioned that China Baoan has an astonishing reserves of graphite ore.　　However, China Baoan (000009, close to 20.46 yuan) has earlier this month and 15th issued a clarification bulletin denied that there are graphite ore, "graphite door" is the responsibility of baoan like "ball" as kicked to the brokerage. Unable to withstand the pressure of public opinion, Xiang-CAI Securities first made a "counterattack."　　Recently, "Daily economic news" received a clarification letter from the Hunan Treasury securities, there are two main content: first, Xiang-wealth securities is not the first release of the report pointed out that the national treasure of the company has graphite ore securities brokerage; Second, the research paper on the information from China Baoan and its subsidiaries published publicly. First listed companies to clarify, the responsibility to push all clean, followed by a brokerage statement, said the research report information from the listed companies.　　So who's lying?　　Xiang-Finance securities in the first response had mentioned in the report Bao Anzi Company has a large number of graphite mines, a lot of brokerages, Xiang-wealth securities is one of them.　　September 6, 2010, Hunan Securities issued a report called "Baoan, China: Real estate and the value of new energy significantly underestimated," the report has three signatures, respectively, Dr Yeung Sum, Hou Wentao and Xu Guangfu. On page 11th of the report, a section of the content of the special introduction of the graphite ore resources in Baoan, the report mentioned "2008 company joint venture in Heilongjiang Baoan New Energy Investment Co., Ltd., the current equity accounted for 90%, this company can provide nearly 268 million tons of reserves for Betry, suitable for lithium ion two times battery of high-quality graphite Mineral Resources To ensure stable and continuous supply of raw materials. "In response to the market for its graphite ore, the voice of Doubt, Baoan issued a notice on March 15, said that the subsidiary's prospecting Rights have entered the approval process, but can not determine whether to obtain the right to prospecting, and can not determine whether the acquisition of the right to explore the mine.　　Baoan This statement, clearly indicated that it does not have the above-mentioned brokerage report of the graphite ore. Since the legal effect of the bulletin is clearly denied that the brokerage "fraud"?　　The daily economic news then contacted several brokers and researchers who had written related reports, but respondents were tight-lipped. Until March 23, Xiang Financial Securities first responded to the "daily economic news" sent a "letter on the China Baoan Research Report," a total of two items, "1, the company issued September 6, 2010 on the China Baoan Research Report, It is not the first domestic report that China National Treasure of the company has graphite ore brokerage report, please verify. 2, the company on the China Baoan Research report above, its source of information from China Baoan and its subsidiaries publicly released information. "The researcher said that the responsibility is not in the yesterday (March 24), the reporter interviewed the Hunan Financial Securities Research Report of a researcher. He said, "before the media said we first reported that he (China Baoan) has graphite ore, it feels like we are fabricating data, so we make a clarification." He stated that the clarification was issued. "We are implicated, and we are not responsible."　　He looked very helpless.　　The above clarification letter mentioned: "The report is from the Chinese Baoan and its subsidiaries publicly released information," If this statement is true, then the Hunan Financial securities will be "fooled" by Bao ' an? Xiang Fortune Securities The above researchers replied: "We do not comment, our intention is to tell the news media, the responsibility of the incident is not ours, our report is no problem." Other things only the public can judge themselves, or the news media to continue to dig, or regulators, government agencies to do the investigation, but these are not our business, not our responsibility. "In addition, careful investors found that the Hunan Securities report mentioned in the 260 million tons of graphite ore reserves, has appeared in the China Baoan subsidiary Betry official online, but the current page has been technology processing, can not be opened."　　But through the previous screenshot, it is clearly written on the page that "Betry has nearly 268 million tons of reserves, suitable for lithium ion two times battery of high-quality graphite mineral resources, to ensure that the supply of raw materials stable, continuous", in addition, also with a picture. Look forward to regulatory intervention in Baoan graphite ore doubts, from the beginning of March, the first company to deny the beginning, has been "fermented" nearly January, at present, a growing trend.　　During the period of Bao ' an, but the end result is listed companies to push off the responsibility, and then is questioned the dissemination of false information securities broker issued a statement, said the information from listed companies, brokers themselves right. So who's lying?　　We are not sure, but it is certain that ordinary investors have suffered losses in the process. Bao ' An graphite mine farce urgently needed from the regulatory authority, otherwise the lack of referee "Buck" game will continue. Responsible Editor: NF042