Reply to "XML creator Tim Bray considers. Net three major issues"

From: http://www.jdon.com/jive/article.jsp? Forum = 106 & Thread = 12805

Both the authority and the predicted Scientist believe that. Net is a threat to Java. In fact, it is a lie. Technically, it is very good, but it has three major fatal disadvantages:

1. It has not gone through the 80/20. Java release from 1.0, and now enters the Middle-aged maturity, this development process is very smooth and natural. On the contrary,. NET is like a full-blown kitchen device. It is too hasty and leaves too many problems to happen and solve one day. (That is to say, it is difficult to say that the use of. NET is quite smooth without passing the test of time. Is it possible for. Net to take a few days to do something similar to Java for several years? The answer is no)

2 .. net was launched by a company with a long history of developing desktop systems. There are many functions that focus on how to build a desktop system. I'm sorry, many commercial systems: putting business logic on the server side and using web as the carrier platform does not have any relationship or interest with the desktop system.

3 .. net is an agenda launched by Microsoft. It is as broad as the earth and as tall as the sky, but it is rare in the world of CIOs and technical buyers. I think this is. net.

The above is taken from the TSS website. url:
Http://www.theserverside.com/news/thread.tss? Thread_id = 24530

Below is my reply:

1. first. net draws on a lot of previous successes and failures in IT technology, and is a platform without historical burdens. net has been launched for more than four years and should be highly competitive. The so-called hero by time and experience is irrational. A few days is even more exaggerated than a few years!

2. What Java has just launched is to focus on the desktop, but the failure of hotspot avoids sun from taking the server segment route. J2EE ConceptProgramIt also began to mature from.
At the beginning,. Net was committed to cross-platform services. ASP. NET was superior to JSP, and Web Services was ahead of the industry. In combination with COM +, webfarm is no worse than J2EE at all.

3. undeniable. net is a very ambitious goal. Is there anything wrong with it. java has been lost for a while. Most CIOs have come from UNIX, and they have always been biased against Microsoft's technology. It may be related to nt4. Look at 64-bit Windows2003, and 64-bit SQL Server, the same price, look at that good performance. These CIOs think UNIX is profound, understand few people, and make achievements (this metaphor should be better than "a few days and a few years !)
 

Respond to your comments!