Is it a true discovery, or a shameful depravity?

Is it a true discovery, or a shameful depravity?

--comment on Mr Pro's "tension of speculation--a new exploration of Hegel's Dialectics"

Paper/Earth Dust 2020

Do not carry meanness, first to prepare a temporary outline:

intro . What Mr Pro called "discovery" of the two major elements of Hegel's dialectics and its (self) negation as the core/soul point of dialectics. The attitude towards the Marxist classics. The attitude towards Chinese (ancient) philosophy. The attitude towards modern Western philosophy. Mr. Pro promised something.

One, dialectics, negation . Negation and affirmation, negation. Negative process (conversion process), negative phase/link, etc. Negation and inevitability.

negation and contradiction . Amazingly, a "proficient" in Hegel's Dialectics [and perhaps also the Marxist philosophy] is afraid and fearful of dialectical contradictions, attempting to circumvent dialectical contradictions, even at the expense of distorting dialectical contradictions. Since 1992 the past more than 10 years *, on the other hand, but kept loudly called Engels to analyze dialectics as the three laws of Dialectics as the "performance" of the level and not to give the negation of the negative "should" pay attention to, Lenin, and so also do not pay much attention to the negation of the negative, Mao Zedong is also "do not recognize what the negation of And "He also confuses the difference between contradictions and differences"--in Mr Pro's view he "does not understand" contradictions/dialectics-because Mr Pro believes that "contradictions must obey excluded middle, there is no middle thing." Anything, as long as there is color, it is not black is not black, only these two choices, there can be no middle. You say there is a color that is neither black nor dark, then you are contradicting yourself ... "it is said that this is also known in Hegel." --Look, this is Mr. Pro's "mastery" of Hegel's Dialectics, dialectics and dialectical contradiction, the logical contradiction and dialectical contradiction are all "Shen Qing" in "porridge".

Second, dialectics, negation of the negative. Marx and Engels's basic position on this issue and what "legacy" he left behind to the future people. Why Lenin did not continue to "develop" on this issue (Mao Zedong in this regard is consistent with Lenin). Mr Pro's "bold" assertion of negation is negation: asserting in the premise that (true) negation is consistent, which makes the second negation happen, and "boldly" infers (from) negation is negation.

Thirdly, the core of dialectics is that negation and negation are the status in Dialectics . Mr Pro's willingness to "bench-warmer" "rigorous" academic style is particularly prominent here, Swagger played a word game-qiatouquwei, counter switch and so on. At the same time also left a long string of almost deceiving-style around/around open dialectical contradiction walk of the footsteps. Really worthy of the "real academic value" of academic works!

four, Reflection . Reflection and philosophical thinking. Reflection and Dialectics, negation, contradiction. Thinking and reflection, the paradox of reflection and its relationship with introspection.

Five *, Marxist philosophy . The "horse" is isolated in the "Enlies Mao" queue with the "most favored nation", Mr Pro-style "in Split" attempt to conquer the method.

Six *, Chinese philosophy . Historical nihilism. Lu Xun as an example, but do not say anything else, Mr. Lu Xun hated "false foreign devil".

seven *, modern Western philosophy , existentialism and so on. "Let me have my head." Heidegger and his old age. Derrida. Gadamer.

Eight *, the dilemma of Western philosophy . "The word must be called Greece" phenomenon. The dilemma of Hegel's philosophy. The fundamental difference of Chinese and Western philosophy and its main manifestation, the future way.

Nine *, the relationship between the phenomenology of Spirit and Hegel's philosophical system, or the position of Hegel's philosophical system. On the phenomenology of Mr. Pro into Marxist philosophy.

10 *, the beginning of Hegel's philosophy .

conclusions . What Mr Pro called the "two major elements" of Hegel's Dialectics and (since) negation as the core/soul of Dialectics is the true discovery, or the rotten mire, the shameful depravity? Can word games be very good at "communicating" and "rigorous" academic style/research? Future direction.

Here is a brief explanation, the core content of the first to explore, mainly is Mr. Pro so-called "discovery" namely Hegel dialectics two major elements-(self) negation and reflection-and the negation as the core of dialectics/soul of the point of view. These contents, especially (from) negation, constitute the basis and core of the dialectical tension-the new exploration of Hegel's dialectics. The rest of the content-mainly those with the * number-will probably be suspended for the future.

2014.12.10 Grass

Main references:

"Speculative tension--a new exploration of Hegel's Dialectics" pro Hunan Education Press August 1992 1th Edition

"In addition: the tension of speculation--a new exploration of Hegel's Dialectics" pro The December 2008 1th edition of the Commercial Press

"Speculative tension--a new exploration of Hegel's Dialectics" pro The Commercial Press September 2014 1th Edition/3rd Brush "

"The speech of Hegel's Dialectics" Pro Peking University Press October 2005 1th Edition/1th Brush

"Pro Hegel" pro Peking University Press April 2006 1th Edition/1th Brush

"The new solution of practical materialism: the dimension of Phenomenology" Pro Wuhan University Press October 2007 1th Edition/1th Brush

The comparison of Chinese and Western culture 11 Pro Hunan Education Press December 2007 1th Edition/1th Brush

"The Methodology of Philosophy History 14" pro Chongqing University Press March 2008 1th Edition/1th Brush

* Hegel < Phenomenology > Punctuation (first volume) Pro July 2014 1th edition/1th Brush

"New critique" pro Hubei Education Press March 2001 1th Edition/1th Brush

* "New Critique" Pro Peking University Press January 2008 1th Edition/1th Brush

"Little Logic" (Germany) Hegel Helin translation of the Commercial Press July 1980 2nd edition March 1995 Beijing 11th Brush

logic ( Juan) (Germany) Hegel Yang Yizhi Translation of the Commercial Press February 1966 1th edition September 1982 Beijing 5th Brush

logic ( lower volume) (Germany) Hegel Yang Yizhi Translation of the Commercial Press December 1976 1th edition September 1982 Beijing 3rd Brush

"Phenomenology of Spirit" (German) Hegel Helin Wang Lixing Translation of the Commercial Press June 1979 2nd edition June 1983 4th Brush

Phenomenology of Spirit (Helin) (Germany) Hegel Wang Lixing Translation of the Commercial Press April 1979 1th edition April 1981 2nd Brush

"Lectures on Philosophical History" (first volume) (Germany) Hegel Helin Wang Taiqing Translation of the Commercial Press September 1959 1th edition August 1983 Beijing 6th Brush

Lecture on Philosophical History (vol. II) (Germany) Hegel Helin Wang Taiqing Translation of the Commercial Press June 1960 1th edition August 1983 Beijing 5th Brush

"Lectures on Philosophical History" (vol. III) (Germany) Hegel Helin Wang Taiqing Translation of the Commercial Press December 1959 1th edition August 1983 Beijing 7th Brush

Lecture on Philosophical History (volume fourth) (Germany) Hegel Helin Wang Taiqing Translation of the Commercial Press December 1978 1th edition August 1983 Beijing 3rd Brush

"Barmanides" [Ancient Greece] Plato Chen Kang the Commercial Press published August 1982 1th Edition May 1999 4th Brush

Metaphysics [ Ancient Greece] Aristotle's translation of the Wu Shoupeng Commercial Press published December 1959 1th Edition March 1995 Beijing 8th Brush

The complete works of Marx and Engels, 2nd Edition, Volume X, etc.

The complete Works of Lenin, 2nd edition, Volume 55th, etc.

Other temporary text is noted.

Is it a true discovery, or a shameful depravity?